About the Retention Election for California Appellate Justices

When Santa Barbara County voters open their November 2026 ballots, they'll find an unfamiliar category of contest: a list of California appellate court justices, each asking a simple yes-or-no question — should they keep their jobs? No opponents will appear beside them. No campaign rhetoric will fill the airwaves. It's a process called judicial retention, and this year it applies to a bench that directly shapes Santa Barbara County law: the Second District Court of Appeal.
The Santa Barbara Independent published a detailed explainer on October 7, 2026, written by a member of that very bench — the Presiding Justice of Division Six of the Second District, who also serves in downtown Ventura. The justice, who spent 22 years as a Ventura County Superior Court judge before joining the appellate court in 2023, used the piece to walk voters through how justices are appointed, evaluated, and retained, and to ask for "yes" votes across the board.
Why the Second District Matters Locally
The Second District Court of Appeal hears appeals from superior court decisions in four counties: Los Angeles, Ventura, Santa Barbara, and San Luis Obispo. It comprises eight divisions. Division Six, based in Ventura, has long been the division most closely tied to cases originating on the Central Coast, meaning its published opinions shape the legal landscape for Santa Barbara residents, businesses, and local government alike.
Every California appellate justice must periodically stand for retention, the Independent's piece explained. Unlike other elected offices, retention races are uncontested by design — no challenger can run against a sitting justice. Voters simply vote "yes" or "no" on whether each justice remains in office, and each must receive a majority of yes votes to continue serving.
A Vetting Process Measured in Years of Scrutiny
The article's most substantive contribution is its step-by-step account of how someone becomes an appellate justice in California — a process the author described as long and extensive.
Candidates must first have practiced law for at least 10 years. From there, hopefuls submit a detailed application to the governor's office, which may route the file to one of eight regional Judicial Selection Advisory Committees. These committees — made up of judges and lawyers from diverse backgrounds — interview people who know the candidate and issue a confidential report rating the applicant as "not qualified," "qualified," "well qualified," or "exceptionally well qualified."
Candidates who advance face a second, independent evaluation by the Commission on Judicial Nominees Evaluation, a body of up to 38 nonpartisan public members, lawyers, and former judicial officers. According to the piece, JNE sends confidential questionnaires to hundreds of judges and lawyers and may contact as many as 75 people who have worked with the candidate. A three-member panel then interviews the candidate — an interview that can take hours — before the full commission votes on a rating.
Only then does the governor's Judicial Appointments Secretary interview the candidate, and only then can the governor formally nominate them to the Court of Appeal. The nomination triggers a final investigation by the California Department of Justice, whose findings go to the Commission on Judicial Appointments — made up of the Chief Justice of California, the state Attorney General, and a senior Presiding Justice. That commission holds a public hearing where members of the public may speak for or against the nominee, and at least two of the three commissioners must vote to approve.
How Voters Can Judge the Judges
For voters wondering how to evaluate justices they've likely never heard of, the article pointed to two safeguards. First, the California Code of Judicial Conduct requires appellate justices to be "faithful to the law, regardless of partisan interests, public clamor, or fear of criticism." Second, the California Commission on Judicial Performance reviews complaints against judges and justices and can impose discipline up to and including removal from office; its public discipline decisions are available for anyone to read.
Notably, the author stated that none of the appellate justices on the November 2026 ballot have been disciplined by the Commission on Judicial Performance.
The Local Takeaway
For Santa Barbara readers, the retention question is less about any single controversy than about the machinery of justice that reviews trial court rulings from the Santa Barbara courthouse. Appellate justices don't campaign in the traditional sense — ethical rules sharply limit what they can say beyond their written opinions — which is why explainer pieces like the Independent's, authored by a sitting justice, serve as one of the few direct lines of communication between the bench and voters.
The author closed with an appeal grounded in process rather than politics: every justice on the ballot has survived the multi-layered vetting described above, has taken an oath to support and defend the U.S. and California constitutions, and, in the author's words, cares deeply about the judicial system, access to justice, and the rule of law.
Santa Barbara voters can review the full list of Second District justices on their sample ballots before Election Day in November 2026. The Independent's original piece is available here, and records of judicial discipline, if any, can be checked through the California Commission on Judicial Performance.
Reported by 805.life
Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: Santa Barbara Independent.
City
Santa BarbaraAdditional Reporting
Santa Barbara IndependentPublished
October 7, 2026
Reported and written by 805.life
Explore Santa BarbaraAll Santa Barbara NewsMore News from Santa Barbara
Santa BarbaraThe Donnys
If you've been following Santa Barbara politics lately, you may have heard folks talking about "The Donnys" — and no, it's not a new band or a restaurant opening. The Santa Barbara Independent recently ran a piece with a headline that says it all: these are the last thing we want to vote for. It's a wry, knowing nod to the sometimes frustrating reality of local elections, where the choices on the ballot can feel less like inspiration and more like a civic chore. Here on the Central Coast, we care deeply about our community, and that means paying attention even when the options aren't exciting. The Independent has a long history of holding local power accountable, and this piece is another example of their sharp-eyed coverage. Whether you're a seasoned voter or new to the area, it's a reminder that local politics shapes everything from housing to highway projects. So as we look ahead to upcoming elections, let's stay engaged — even when the ballot feels underwhelming. After all, showing up is half the battle, and our neighborhoods are worth it.
Santa BarbaraSBCC Women’s Soccer Rolls to 6-1 Win Over San Diego Miramar in SoCal Regional Round 2
What a night for the Vaqueros! Our SBCC women's soccer team showed up in front of a packed La Playa Stadium crowd and put on a show, rolling past San Diego Miramar 6-1 in the second round of the SoCal Regional. The No. 6 seed is now 18-4 on the season and looks like a squad hitting its stride at exactly the right time. There's something special about playoff soccer under the lights at La Playa — the ocean air, the hometown crowd, and a team that clearly feeds off that energy. The Vaqueros struck early and never let up, and you could feel the momentum building from the opening whistle. Big congrats to the players and coaching staff. If you haven't caught a match yet this season, now's the time to get out there and support our local team as they chase a regional title. Thanks to Noozhawk for keeping us posted on the run.
Santa BarbaraSanta Barbara Man Accused of Concealing Body in West Beach Apartment Rearrested While Out on Bail
Our West Beach neighborhood is breathing a little easier this week after news that Kenneth Tompkins, the man accused of concealing a body in an apartment, was rearrested while out on bail. According to the Santa Barbara Independent, the arrest came after he failed to keep his GPS monitor charged — a small detail that reminds us how closely monitored release agreements really are. For those of us who live and work near the waterfront, this story hits close to home. West Beach is a tight-knit community, and any crime here tends to ripple through our daily routines. It's a good reminder to keep an eye out for each other and to stay informed about public safety developments. We'll be watching how this case unfolds. In the meantime, let's continue looking out for our neighbors and supporting one another. Have thoughts or tips? Reach out to us at 805.life.