Santa Barbara

Developer of 191-Unit Housing Project on Carpinteria Bluffs Scales It Down and Opens It Up  

Developer of 191-Unit Housing Project on Carpinteria Bluffs Scales It Down and Opens It Up  

A controversial housing development proposed for the Carpinteria bluffs is getting a major overhaul before the Carpinteria City Council's Monday, November 23 review, with the developer unveiling an alternative that would scale back construction on the contested Tee Time site while shifting affordable housing to a neighboring parcel.

The revision, reported by the Santa Barbara Independent, comes after more than two years of friction between out-of-town developers, city officials, and a community that has long guarded the oceanfront bluffs as some of the South Coast's most treasured open space.

What Changed in the New Proposal

The original application for "The Farm," submitted to the city in 2024, proposed 191 units — single-family homes and townhouses — on a 5885 Carpinteria Avenue parcel that currently holds the Tee Time driving range and the Carp Children's Farm School. The site sits next to the Carpinteria Bluffs Nature Preserve and the Seal Sanctuary, land prized for its native habitat, wildlife corridors, and public trails.

The new alternative, which developer Paul Brenneke will present to the council, incorporates the adjacent S&S Seeds property at 6155-6175 Carpinteria Avenue and splits the project across the two parcels. Key changes include:

  • Reducing for-sale units at the Tee Time site from 191 to 175
  • Expanding affordable units from the originally proposed 39 to as many as 87, concentrated on the S&S Seeds site
  • Cutting developed lot coverage by roughly 21 percent — from 105,000 square feet to 82,500 square feet — with the recovered area devoted to landscaping and open space
  • Dedicating portions of both sites to the city as open space
  • Improving ocean views from the nature preserve and adding public parking to preserve coastal access
  • Relocating the Carp Children's Farm School and preserving existing trails

Brenneke, an Oregon-based investor who purchased the land for $15 million, said in a statement that years of "listening to the residents of Carpinteria" made clear "how deeply people care about preserving what makes Carpinteria special." Working with People's Self-Help Housing — a San Luis Obispo–based nonprofit affordable housing developer active across the Central Coast — Brenneke is proposing what he described as an approximately $27 million investment in affordable housing on the S&S Seeds property.

"I believe this alternative demonstrates that housing and preservation do not have to be competing priorities," Brenneke said.

Why Builder's Remedy Limits the City's Options

The project has moved forward under California's builder's remedy law, which exempts qualifying developments from local zoning rules in cities without a state-compliant housing element, as long as a portion of the units are set aside as affordable. For The Farm, that threshold is 20 percent — which the original 39 affordable units met.

That legal framework has left Carpinteria squeezed between vocal community opposition and state pressure to produce housing. The city must plan for 901 new residential units by 2031 under its state-mandated housing allocation, and refusing a builder's remedy project outright carries litigation risk.

Early public meetings on the project drew overflow crowds, dominated by opponents though sprinkled with YIMBY-minded residents who acknowledged the city's housing shortfall. According to the Independent, the Carpinteria Valley has some of the tightest housing inventory on the South Coast, and workforce housing has been a chronic concern for local farms, nurseries, and small businesses.

Opponents Say the Alternative Grows the Project

Not everyone is persuaded. The Citizens for the Carpinteria Bluffs, the group leading opposition, says the alternative actually makes things worse by folding the S&S Seeds site into the development footprint. Group president Patrick Crooks said the new plan increases the total number of units proposed on the bluffs from 191 to 262.

Crooks told the Independent the alternative came "out of left field" and was placed on the council agenda at the 11th hour. The group is urging residents to attend Monday's meeting and press the council to reject residential development on the bluffs entirely.

The organization's position has been unwavering: it wants the land donated or sold for full preservation, arguing that while housing is needed, it can be built elsewhere in Carpinteria — away from a coastal landscape residents describe as sacred and irreplaceable.

The debate echoes decades of fights over the bluffs. Community fundraising in the 1990s helped secure the Carpinteria Bluffs Nature Preserve itself, cementing a local tradition of treating the headlands as permanently protected public land in the public imagination, even where private inholdings remained.

What Comes Next

Monday's City Council review is a study session on the alternative, not a final approval — but it will signal whether the revised concept gains traction with the body that will ultimately weigh the project's entitlements, and whether the concessions are enough to soften community resistance.

For Santa Barbara-area residents, the stakes cut both ways. A project that delivers up to 87 income-restricted units in partnership with an established nonprofit housing developer would be one of the larger affordable housing commitments on the South Coast in recent years. But it would also put hundreds of new homes on a coastal bluff whose preservation has been a generations-long cause in Carpinteria.

Brenneke, for his part, framed the revision as a genuine attempt at middle ground. "I understand and appreciate both perspectives," he said of the competing concerns over preservation and housing scarcity. "Those conversations have led us to explore an alternative that I believe offers a meaningful improvement for the community."

Whether that improvement satisfies a community that has spent decades defending the bluffs — and a council balancing state housing mandates against local sentiment — will begin to come into focus Monday night at Carpinteria City Hall.

Reported by 805.life

Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: Santa Barbara Independent.

Additional Reporting

Santa Barbara Independent

Published

November 21, 2026

Reported and written by 805.life

Explore Santa BarbaraAll Santa Barbara News

More News from Santa Barbara

The DonnysSanta Barbara
Santa Barbara Independent· Nov 21, 2026

The Donnys

If you've been following Santa Barbara politics lately, you may have heard folks talking about "The Donnys" — and no, it's not a new band or a restaurant opening. The Santa Barbara Independent recently ran a piece with a headline that says it all: these are the last thing we want to vote for. It's a wry, knowing nod to the sometimes frustrating reality of local elections, where the choices on the ballot can feel less like inspiration and more like a civic chore. Here on the Central Coast, we care deeply about our community, and that means paying attention even when the options aren't exciting. The Independent has a long history of holding local power accountable, and this piece is another example of their sharp-eyed coverage. Whether you're a seasoned voter or new to the area, it's a reminder that local politics shapes everything from housing to highway projects. So as we look ahead to upcoming elections, let's stay engaged — even when the ballot feels underwhelming. After all, showing up is half the battle, and our neighborhoods are worth it.

SBCC Women’s Soccer Rolls to 6-1 Win Over San Diego Miramar in SoCal Regional Round 2Santa Barbara
Noozhawk· Nov 21, 2026

SBCC Women’s Soccer Rolls to 6-1 Win Over San Diego Miramar in SoCal Regional Round 2

What a night for the Vaqueros! Our SBCC women's soccer team showed up in front of a packed La Playa Stadium crowd and put on a show, rolling past San Diego Miramar 6-1 in the second round of the SoCal Regional. The No. 6 seed is now 18-4 on the season and looks like a squad hitting its stride at exactly the right time. There's something special about playoff soccer under the lights at La Playa — the ocean air, the hometown crowd, and a team that clearly feeds off that energy. The Vaqueros struck early and never let up, and you could feel the momentum building from the opening whistle. Big congrats to the players and coaching staff. If you haven't caught a match yet this season, now's the time to get out there and support our local team as they chase a regional title. Thanks to Noozhawk for keeping us posted on the run.

Santa Barbara Man Accused of Concealing Body in West Beach Apartment Rearrested While Out on Bail Santa Barbara
Santa Barbara Independent· Nov 21, 2026

Santa Barbara Man Accused of Concealing Body in West Beach Apartment Rearrested While Out on Bail 

Our West Beach neighborhood is breathing a little easier this week after news that Kenneth Tompkins, the man accused of concealing a body in an apartment, was rearrested while out on bail. According to the Santa Barbara Independent, the arrest came after he failed to keep his GPS monitor charged — a small detail that reminds us how closely monitored release agreements really are. For those of us who live and work near the waterfront, this story hits close to home. West Beach is a tight-knit community, and any crime here tends to ripple through our daily routines. It's a good reminder to keep an eye out for each other and to stay informed about public safety developments. We'll be watching how this case unfolds. In the meantime, let's continue looking out for our neighbors and supporting one another. Have thoughts or tips? Reach out to us at 805.life.