Atascadero

San Miguel CSD election results shift, candidates trade leads

San Miguel CSD election results shift, candidates trade leads

Election night was not the end of the story in San Miguel. As election workers continue tallying ballots following the Nov. 3 contest, the races for three seats on the San Miguel Community Services District (CSD) board have tightened — and in two cases, the leaders have changed, according to the New Times SLO (Atascadero).

The Nov. 10 vote tallies show John McClure holding onto his lead in the five-candidate race for two full four-year terms, but the fight for the second seat has flipped. Andrew Havard has moved past John Butler II, and the two are now separated by just four votes. Meanwhile, in the short-term race to fill the remainder of a vacant board seat, former board member Berkley Baker has overtaken Raynette Martines, who led on election night.

The results remain preliminary, and additional ballots have yet to be counted before the election is certified.

Four votes apart in the race for two seats

In the contest for two four-year seats, McClure leads with 141 votes, or 25.5 percent, followed by Havard with 129 votes, or 23.3 percent, and Butler with 125 votes, or 22.6 percent. Incumbents Rod Smiley and Owen Davis trail with 90 and 67 votes, respectively.

That ordering marks a shift from election night, when McClure and Butler held the top two positions. With four votes separating Havard and Butler, the second seat could hinge on the remaining ballots — a margin small enough that late-arriving mail ballots and any cured provisional ballots could decide the outcome.

The race to fill the final two years of a vacant seat is similarly close. Baker now holds 161 votes, or 51.3 percent, compared with Martines' 153 votes, or 48.7 percent. Martines had initially led with 53.1 percent of the vote on election night.

"We're just so neck and neck," Martines told New Times. "It's just anyone's race at this moment."

A board reshaped by division

The stakes go beyond the raw vote counts. The outcome could reshape a majority of the five-member board, which has spent nearly two years mired in disagreements over district leadership, local control, and infrastructure priorities.

The board has operated with only four members since Director John Green died in late 2025, according to New Times. Efforts to appoint a replacement failed after directors repeatedly split 2-2, leaving the seat vacant until this month's election. Martines, who served on the board from 2019 through 2024, was among four applicants interviewed for the vacancy earlier this year. Despite receiving nine letters of community support, she failed to secure enough votes for an appointment.

The district has also wrestled with whether to explore dissolving the CSD and transferring its services to San Luis Obispo County. The proposal was discussed twice in 2025, but the board took no action toward dissolution — leaving the question for the incoming board to contend with.

Candidates point to board dysfunction

The candidates themselves have made clear that the board's internal conflict is a central issue.

McClure, a San Miguel resident of 30 years who has served on the San Miguel Advisory Council for 14 years, previously told New Times that conflict among directors had made him hesitant to seek a board seat at all.

"One of the things that shied me away was the chaos that went on in these meetings," McClure said during an October candidate forum.

Butler, a local business owner, similarly identified division as the pressing issue facing the district.

"The most pressing issue I see is division, both within the current board and between the board and the community," Butler previously told New Times.

Martines said she hopes the election brings greater cooperation among directors and renewed attention to infrastructure projects already underway.

"I hope that the board can … do that in a reasonable … no-drama kind of way, and be respectful of each other and opinions," she said.

What's next for San Miguel — and why neighbors should care

For residents of Atascadero and the surrounding North County, the San Miguel races are worth watching for what they signal about small-special-district governance across the region. The incoming board will oversee several infrastructure projects, including water and wastewater improvements, as the community weighs additional housing and downtown development.

San Miguel, an unincorporated community of roughly 2,500 people at the northern edge of San Luis Obispo County, relies on its CSD for core municipal services. When a five-member board is deadlocked 2-2 and can't even fill a vacancy, routine decisions about water systems and development can stall — a dynamic familiar to watchers of small-district politics throughout the 805.

Regardless of the final outcome, Martines said she was encouraged by the level of civic engagement, particularly after years in which board members often ran unopposed.

"This is the first time in a lot of years that board members haven't just walked on," she said. "We've had a true election this year, and I think that's wonderful and exciting for our community."

With votes still to be counted and margins as narrow as four ballots, San Miguel residents — and anyone following North County governance — will need to wait for the county's official certification to know who will actually take their seat at the dais. Until then, as Martines put it, it's anyone's race.

This article is based on reporting by [New Times SLO (Atascadero)](https://www.newtimesslo.com/san-miguel-csd-election-results-shift-candidates-trade-leads/), published Nov. 12, 2026. Vote totals reflect the Nov. 10 tally and are subject to change as additional ballots are counted.

Reported by 805.life

Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: New Times SLO (Atascadero).

Additional Reporting

New Times SLO (Atascadero)

Published

November 12, 2026

Reported and written by 805.life

Explore AtascaderoAll Atascadero News

More News from Atascadero

Paso school board pushes back against credit card allegationsAtascadero
New Times SLO (Atascadero)· Nov 19, 2026

Paso school board pushes back against credit card allegations

Paso Robles school board trustees are pushing back against financial misconduct allegations raised by one of their own, Trustee Nathan Williams. At the Nov. 10 meeting, Williams defended the board's duty to ask hard questions and pursue oversight, while also stressing the need to communicate accurately and distinguish suspicion from fact. The dispute centers on credit card allegations, though details remain sparse in the New Times SLO (Atascadero) report. For those of us in Atascadero and across the 805, school board decisions hit close to home—they shape budgets, trust, and the quality of education our kids receive. When trustees publicly disagree about financial oversight, it's worth paying attention, even if the full story is still unfolding. It's a reminder that local governance isn't always tidy, but transparency matters. We'll keep watching how this plays out. In the meantime, it's a good moment to remind ourselves that asking questions of our elected officials is part of being an engaged community—respectfully and factually.

Pismo Beach considers rewriting pole sign ordinanceAtascadero
New Times SLO (Atascadero)· Nov 19, 2026

Pismo Beach considers rewriting pole sign ordinance

Pismo Beach is taking a second look at its pole sign rules, and honestly, it's about time. At the Nov. 17 City Council meeting, council members asked staff to explore updating the outdated sign code so existing pole signs can be grandfathered in and business owners can actually repair them. If you've ever driven through Pismo and noticed those tall signs, you know they're part of the local business landscape. Here on the Central Coast, small businesses already face enough hurdles without a sign code that makes simple repairs a headache. This move signals Pismo is willing to work with its business community rather than against it. New Times SLO (Atascadero) reported the story, and it's worth keeping an eye on—especially if you own or frequent a shop that depends on that roadside visibility. It's not a done deal yet, just a direction for staff to evaluate. But it's a good reminder that local government can adapt when rules stop making sense. We'll be watching to see what comes back to the council.

Arroyo Grande approves long-awaited general plan updateAtascadero
New Times SLO (Atascadero)· Nov 19, 2026

Arroyo Grande approves long-awaited general plan update

Big news for our neighbors in Arroyo Grande — after five years of work and three different City Council iterations, the city's General Plan update finally got the green light. This is the blueprint that will guide growth and development for the next 20 years, and it's been a long time coming since the last update back in 2001. For those of us here in Atascadero, it's a good reminder of how much these long-range plans shape our daily lives — housing, traffic, open space, all of it. Whether you're commuting down the 101 or just curious about how our neighboring cities are planning for the future, this one's worth a read. New Times SLO (Atascadero) has the full story. It's always encouraging to see local governments finally wrap up these big-picture projects. Here's hoping the plan serves Arroyo Grande well for decades to come.