Atascadero

Scott Newton is poised to be Pismo Beach’s next mayor

Scott Newton is poised to be Pismo Beach’s next mayor

Pismo Beach appears set to have a new mayor, and the outcome carries implications well beyond that city's borders for Atascadero and other North County residents who flock to the coast's beaches, hotels, and conference center each year. Pismo Beach City Councilmember Scott Newton holds a commanding lead in the city's mayoral race, according to the latest San Luis Obispo County vote counts, while a ballot measure that would reshape the office itself — Measure E-26 — is also on track to pass.

As of the Nov. 10 count, Newton had won nearly 68 percent of the vote, far ahead of his most vocal challenger, Cynthia Replogle, who earned 27 percent. A third candidate, Shelby Bowen, took 5 percent, according to the New Times SLO (Atascadero), which first reported the tally.

Newton did not respond to media inquiries by press time, but he acknowledged his early lead on Facebook hours after polls closed on Nov. 3. "Thank you to the voters of Pismo Beach, the early results are looking extremely promising," his Nov. 4 post read.

An established council voice moves up

Newton has served on the Pismo Beach City Council since 2020 and is a supporter of the Central Coast Blue project, the regional recycled-water effort aimed at reducing reliance on imported water for Five Cities-area communities. His mayoral bid drew endorsements from Mayor Ed Waage, fellow Councilmembers Mary Ann Reiss and Marcia Guthrie, and the Republican Party of San Luis Obispo County.

For Atascadero residents, the leadership change at Pismo Beach matters in practical ways. The coastal city is a major economic and recreational anchor for the entire 805 region, drawing visitors from across North County and generating transient-occupancy tax revenue that helps fund regional infrastructure. Pismo Beach officials have also historically played a role in countywide conversations on water — including the Central Coast Blue project Newton supports — housing, and tourism management, all issues that ripple up the Highway 101 corridor to inland communities like Atascadero.

Measure E-26 would extend mayoral terms to four years

Pismo Beach voters also appear to be approving Measure E-26, a ballot measure Newton backed that would extend the mayoral term from two years to four. The measure had won 54 percent of yes votes in the latest count. If it passes, the change would take effect in 2028 — meaning the winner of the current race would initially serve a two-year term, with the four-year term beginning at the next cycle.

Supporters argue the change would give the mayor more time to pursue long-term policy goals without campaigning essentially nonstop. Replogle, who was endorsed by the SLO County Democratic Party, told New Times she's disappointed by the measure's likelihood of passing, saying it would reduce the mayor's accountability to constituents.

"I'm taking inspiration from Kamala Harris' concession speech two years ago," Replogle said. "She said, 'This is not a time to throw up our hands. This is a time to roll up our sleeves.'"

Replogle said she plans to follow through on a campaign priority regardless of the election's outcome: forming an independent resident advisory panel made up of neighborhood representatives. The panel, she explained via email, "will monitor quality of life metrics (such as number of contacts to resolve code enforcement complaints) and provide a forum for residents to bring their concerns (like evacuation planning) for elevation to the City Council. Because our voices are stronger together."

She also said she will be monitoring the city's promised release of major updates on items including the ADA Transition Plan and the safety, housing, and parks, recreation, and access elements of the city's planning documents.

City Council race separated by four votes

Change is underway for the rest of the Pismo Beach City Council as well. Voters could cast ballots for two candidates in the council race, and the most recent tally showed newcomer Manuel Olivas and incumbent Stacy Inman as the top two vote-getters — separated by just four votes.

Olivas, a local law enforcement officer, led with 1,808 votes, or 32.5 percent of the share, while Inman received 1,804 votes. Neither responded to requests for comment from New Times by press time.

With a margin that narrow, the outcome could shift as county elections officials continue processing late-arriving mail ballots, provisional ballots, and ballots needing signature verification. San Luis Obispo County elections officials typically update vote counts on a rolling basis in the weeks following election day before certifying final results, a process North County voters have seen decide close local races before — including in Atascadero's own tight council contests in prior cycles.

What comes next

County election officials must certify the final results before the new mayor and council members are seated. If the current tallies hold, Newton would succeed Waage as mayor, joined on the council by Olivas and Inman.

The incoming leadership will face a full plate of regional issues: follow-through on Central Coast Blue, the city's ADA and housing planning updates, and ongoing concerns from residents like Replogle about code enforcement responsiveness and evacuation planning — the latter a sensitive topic for any coastal community bordered by wildland hills, and a subject Atascadero residents know well from their own wildfire-preparedness efforts.

Atascadero residents who work in, visit, or do business on the coast will want to watch how the new mayor's priorities take shape once final results are certified. As of now, the message from Pismo Beach voters is clear: continuity, with a side of structural change to the mayor's office itself.

Reported by 805.life

Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: New Times SLO (Atascadero).

Additional Reporting

New Times SLO (Atascadero)

Published

November 12, 2026

Reported and written by 805.life

Explore AtascaderoAll Atascadero News

More News from Atascadero

Paso school board pushes back against credit card allegationsAtascadero
New Times SLO (Atascadero)· Nov 19, 2026

Paso school board pushes back against credit card allegations

Paso Robles school board trustees are pushing back against financial misconduct allegations raised by one of their own, Trustee Nathan Williams. At the Nov. 10 meeting, Williams defended the board's duty to ask hard questions and pursue oversight, while also stressing the need to communicate accurately and distinguish suspicion from fact. The dispute centers on credit card allegations, though details remain sparse in the New Times SLO (Atascadero) report. For those of us in Atascadero and across the 805, school board decisions hit close to home—they shape budgets, trust, and the quality of education our kids receive. When trustees publicly disagree about financial oversight, it's worth paying attention, even if the full story is still unfolding. It's a reminder that local governance isn't always tidy, but transparency matters. We'll keep watching how this plays out. In the meantime, it's a good moment to remind ourselves that asking questions of our elected officials is part of being an engaged community—respectfully and factually.

Pismo Beach considers rewriting pole sign ordinanceAtascadero
New Times SLO (Atascadero)· Nov 19, 2026

Pismo Beach considers rewriting pole sign ordinance

Pismo Beach is taking a second look at its pole sign rules, and honestly, it's about time. At the Nov. 17 City Council meeting, council members asked staff to explore updating the outdated sign code so existing pole signs can be grandfathered in and business owners can actually repair them. If you've ever driven through Pismo and noticed those tall signs, you know they're part of the local business landscape. Here on the Central Coast, small businesses already face enough hurdles without a sign code that makes simple repairs a headache. This move signals Pismo is willing to work with its business community rather than against it. New Times SLO (Atascadero) reported the story, and it's worth keeping an eye on—especially if you own or frequent a shop that depends on that roadside visibility. It's not a done deal yet, just a direction for staff to evaluate. But it's a good reminder that local government can adapt when rules stop making sense. We'll be watching to see what comes back to the council.

Arroyo Grande approves long-awaited general plan updateAtascadero
New Times SLO (Atascadero)· Nov 19, 2026

Arroyo Grande approves long-awaited general plan update

Big news for our neighbors in Arroyo Grande — after five years of work and three different City Council iterations, the city's General Plan update finally got the green light. This is the blueprint that will guide growth and development for the next 20 years, and it's been a long time coming since the last update back in 2001. For those of us here in Atascadero, it's a good reminder of how much these long-range plans shape our daily lives — housing, traffic, open space, all of it. Whether you're commuting down the 101 or just curious about how our neighboring cities are planning for the future, this one's worth a read. New Times SLO (Atascadero) has the full story. It's always encouraging to see local governments finally wrap up these big-picture projects. Here's hoping the plan serves Arroyo Grande well for decades to come.