The Billionaire Tax Could Be Defeated by Two Other Tax Measures. Here’s How

Santa Barbara voters heading to the polls this November will face one of the strangest ballot puzzles California has produced in years: three competing tax measures where a majority "yes" vote on the headline measure might not be enough to make it law.
The measure at the center is Proposition 40, a one-time 5% tax on California residents with a net worth above $1 billion. But as the Santa Barbara Independent reported, republishing reporting by Kristen Hwang of CalMatters, recent polling from the Public Policy Institute of California shows slim majorities of likely voters supporting not just Prop. 40, but also Propositions 41 and 42 — two countermeasures funded largely by billionaires and designed specifically to cancel the wealth tax out.
"I don't think that people at this point realize they're direct countermeasures because there hasn't been much said about 41 and 42," Mark Baldassare, PPIC's polling director, told CalMatters.
How the Three Measures Interact
The mechanics are straightforward even if the politics aren't. If Prop. 40 captures more votes than both Prop. 41 and Prop. 42, the wealth tax takes effect and voids the countermeasures. But if either Prop. 41 or Prop. 42 outpolls Prop. 40, the billionaire tax does not take effect — regardless of whether it won majority support on its own.
Prop. 40 would levy the one-time 5% tax based on residency as of Jan. 1, 2026 — a date that had already passed when the measure qualified for the ballot. That means billionaires who left California afterward would still owe the tax. According to the measure's primary backer, SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, the tax would raise roughly $100 billion, with most of the money directed to healthcare and a smaller portion to education. The union argues the revenue is needed to backfill federal healthcare cuts passed last year. Opponents, including conservatives who argue the Medi-Cal program has grown too expensive, contend new federal policies will help the state trim spending instead.
Prop. 41 takes a more procedural swipe. It would require new tax proposals passed after the start of this year to comply with the state's annual spending limit — a cap voters approved in 1979 at the height of anti-tax sentiment. Because Prop. 40 was not written to comply with that limit, it would automatically run afoul of the provision. Prop. 41 would also require the nonpartisan state auditor to review new tax proposals before they reach voters and identify potential spending cuts in the programs they would fund — with audit costs paid out of tax revenue if a measure passes, or by the state if it fails.
Prop. 42 is the blunter instrument. It would bar new taxes on personal property — businesses, investments, retirement accounts, trusts and art collections — precisely what Prop. 40 targets. It would also prohibit retroactive taxation, blocking the wealth tax's reach back to assets accumulated before the measure takes effect. Either provision alone would be enough to nullify Prop. 40 if the countermeasure wins more votes.
Megan Jones, a tax attorney with Holland and Knight, told CalMatters that Prop. 42 is "a more direct anti-wealth tax proposal," noting the Legislature has tried and failed to pass wealth taxes before. If Prop. 42 passes, she said, it could constrain future legislative attempts as well.
Follow the Money
The spending on the three-measure battle is staggering even by California standards.
Backers of Prop. 40 — primarily SEIU-UHW, with support from the California Democratic Party — have raised about $31 million, mostly from union funds.
The opposition is operating on a different financial plane. Google co-founder Sergey Brin and other billionaires have poured more than $56 million into the No on Prop. 40 committee through a political organization called Building a Better California, according to the CalMatters reporting. That same group is the primary financial backer of Props. 41 and 42, having raised $131 million to promote them. In total, the billionaire-backed effort has amassed more than $187 million to defeat the wealth tax.
The opposition coalition also includes Gov. Gavin Newsom, doctors' groups and clinics. Newsom argues the tax would not provide a long-term fix for California's budget problems and would push wealthy residents and businesses — whose income taxes the state depends on — out of California, ultimately shrinking revenue.
What It Means for Santa Barbara
For Santa Barbara County residents, the practical stakes are less about whether any local household would owe the tax — the $1 billion net worth threshold applies to a vanishingly small number of Californians — and more about what the measures signal for state services and the initiative process itself.
The healthcare funding at the heart of Prop. 40 flows through the same Medi-Cal and safety-net systems that serve thousands of Santa Barbara County residents, and local clinics have watched the state-federal funding fight closely. At the same time, the spectacle of dueling ballot measures funded by nine-figure campaigns has renewed debate about whether California's initiative system increasingly rewards whoever can spend the most to confuse the electorate.
Baldassare said backers of the billionaire tax will have a hard time overcoming voter confusion about the three competing measures — and with PPIC's polling showing slim majorities supporting all of them, confusion may be the decisive factor.
With ballots landing in mailboxes across the 805 in the coming weeks, Santa Barbara voters would do well to read the propositions together rather than one at a time. On this corner of the ballot, a vote for the billionaire tax and a vote against it may look nearly identical — and only the final vote count will settle which one actually becomes law.
Reported by 805.life
Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: Santa Barbara Independent.
City
Santa BarbaraAdditional Reporting
Santa Barbara IndependentPublished
September 27, 2026
Reported and written by 805.life
Explore Santa BarbaraAll Santa Barbara NewsMore News from Santa Barbara
Santa BarbaraGauchos blowout Utah Tech in strong defensive effort
How about those Gauchos? UCSB women's basketball put on a defensive clinic in the Thunderdome this week, holding Utah Tech to just 22 points through three quarters on the way to a 67-40 blowout. Freshman Charlotte Lipkin caught fire from deep with four 3-pointers and a team-high 15 points — a name worth remembering, folks. Senior Zoe Borter and junior Mauriana Hashemian-Orr each chipped in 10, and the Gauchos are now sitting pretty at 5-1 on the young season. For those of us who love catching a game in person, the Thunderdome is one of the best deals in town — affordable tickets, real college-hoops energy, and a team that's fun to root for. Big thanks to KEYT News Channel 3-12 for keeping us posted on our local squads. If you haven't made it out to a game yet this season, this is your sign. Go Gauchos!
Santa BarbaraSanta Barbara High Boys Basketball Drops Heartbreaker to Crespi, 60-57
Dons fans, we know the sting of a close one. Santa Barbara High's boys basketball squad battled Crespi down to the wire Friday night but came up just short, 60-57. It's the kind of game that reminds you why local hoops matter — every possession, every defensive stop, and a gym full of neighbors riding each bounce. The good news? This team gets a full week to regroup before a big matchup with Oaks Christian on December 1. That's plenty of time for Coach and the guys to tighten things up and come back hungry. If you've been meaning to catch a game, that December 1 date is a perfect excuse to pack the stands and show some Dons love. We spotted the final score in the Santa Barbara Independent, and we'll be keeping an eye on how this squad bounces back. Heartbreakers happen — but so do comebacks. See you at the gym.
Santa BarbaraSanta Barbara High Football Struggles Late in 21-10 CIF-SS D6 Semifinal Loss to Beaumont
Tough one for the Golden Tornado faithful Friday night at Peabody Stadium. Santa Barbara High kept it close early, but Beaumont clamped down in the second half and the Dons' CIF-SS Division 6 title chase ended with a 21-10 semifinal loss. If you've stood on those Peabody bleachers on a Friday, you know how much this team meant to the community — and how quiet that final whistle felt. Still, what a run. Getting to a section semifinal is no small thing, and these players gave Santa Barbara a fall to remember. Credit to the coaches and the seniors who led the way. Noozhawk had the full game story, and it's worth a read for anyone who followed the season. So here's to the Dons — the offseason starts now, but the pride doesn't fade. See you back at Peabody next fall.