Deputies found evidence in search for Kristin Smart’s remains

Evidence Discovered in Latest Kristin Smart Search
San Luis Obispo County Sheriff's deputies recovered "several items considered evidentiary in nature" during their latest search for the remains of murder victim Kristin Smart, according to a May 19 press release from the Sheriff's Office. No human remains were found during the operation at the Arroyo Grande home of Susan Flores.
The search, which began May 6, utilized advanced forensic techniques including ground-penetrating radar and soil vapor science at the property on the 500 block of East Branch Street. Soil scientists identified an area in the side yard that showed "results consistent with the possible presence of human remains," according to multiple news reports.
Excavation Follows Soil Testing Results
On May 8, investigators secured an additional search warrant to excavate the identified area. Teams removed large concrete pavers and carefully sifted through soil for evidence related to Smart's 1996 disappearance. The excavation continued through May 9.
Sheriff Ian Parkinson had told reporters during a May 8 press conference that soil testing had produced "positive results consistent with human decomposition," though officials could not confirm whether those results were linked to Smart, CNN reported.
"We believe, based on what we're looking at, scientific evidence, we believe that human remains were there at one time," Parkinson told KSBY, though he cautioned they couldn't confirm specifics.
Background on the Decades-Long Case
Smart, a 19-year-old Cal Poly freshman, disappeared over Memorial Day weekend in 1996 after attending an off-campus party. Paul Flores, a fellow student who was the last person seen with her, was convicted of first-degree murder in October 2022-has-been-convicted-by-jury-of-the) and sentenced to 25 years to life in March 2023.
Prosecutors alleged that Flores killed Smart during an attempted rape. His father, Ruben Flores, was charged as an accessory but was acquitted by a separate jury. Paul Flores' conviction was upheld by the California Court of Appeal in October 2025, and the California Supreme Court denied his petition for review in January 2026.
What This Means for the Investigation
Susan Flores' home has been searched multiple times during the 30-year investigation, but Sheriff Parkinson noted that advances in soil science and ground-penetrating radar technology have enabled more sophisticated analysis. The property owner is considered a person of interest in the case.
"The Sheriff's Office remains fully committed to finding Kristin and bringing her home to her family," the agency stated in its press release. The recovered evidence is currently being analyzed as part of the ongoing investigation.
This latest search underscores law enforcement's continued commitment to the case nearly three decades after Smart's disappearance. While her killer has been convicted and sentenced, the search for her remains continues, offering hope to her family and the Central Coast community that has followed this case for years.
Anyone with information about the case is urged to contact San Luis Obispo County Crime Stoppers at 1-800-549-STOP (7867).
Reported by 805.life
Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: CalCoastNews.
City
San Luis ObispoAdditional Reporting
CalCoastNewsPublished
May 19, 2026
Reported and written by 805.life
Explore San Luis ObispoAll San Luis Obispo NewsMore News from San Luis Obispo
San Luis ObispoJury convicts gang member in fatal shooting on the Pismo Beach Pier
A jury this week convicted 22-year-old Daniel Santillana of assault with a semiautomatic firearm in a fatal shooting on the Pismo Beach Pier back in 2023, and found the crime was committed for the benefit of the Norteño street gang. It's a heavy reminder that even our iconic, postcard-perfect pier isn't immune to the violence that can spill into public spaces. For those of us who walk those planks with our kids and dogs, this news hits close to home. Thanks to CalCoastNews for keeping us informed on the case as it moved through the courts. The conviction won't bring anyone back, but it does send a message that gang violence won't be tolerated on the Central Coast. Let's keep an eye out for our neighbors and continue making Pismo the safe, welcoming place we know it can be.
San Luis ObispoSee how much rainfall fell from storm that soaked San Luis Obispo County
Well, that was a proper soaking. CalCoastNews reports a powerful storm rolled through SLO County on Wednesday, dumping close to 6 inches in some spots — with Arroyo Grande at 2.37 inches, Atascadero 1.77, Cambria 2.72, and Creston 1.29 over the past three days. If you were out on the roads, you know it wasn't pretty. Here in the 805, rain like this is a gift and a headache all at once. Our creeks and reservoirs need every drop, but our hillsides and highways don't always handle it gracefully — flooding and slick conditions made driving dicey for plenty of neighbors. Take a minute to check your gutters, slow down on the backroads, and maybe give a shout to anyone in the low-lying spots. And if you've got a rain total from your corner of the county, we'd love to hear it.
San Luis ObispoMissing teen found deceased in San Luis Obispo
It's with a heavy heart that we share news no parent in our community ever wants to hear. A 16-year-old nonverbal student who left San Luis Obispo High School on Wednesday afternoon was found deceased Thursday near Cuesta Park, according to CalCoastNews. Our thoughts go out to David Bennett's family, his classmates, and the staff and students at SLO High who are processing this loss. For families of children with special needs, this hits especially close to home. Nonverbal teens face unique safety challenges, and our community should be asking what more we can do to keep every student safe between the school bell and the front door. If you or someone you know needs support, reach out to local resources and check on the families around you. We'll be following this story as more details emerge. In the meantime, hold your loved ones a little closer tonight, SLO.