Oversight for Simi landfill agreement nixed

The Simi Valley City Council has rejected a proposal to form a committee to review the city's 2011 agreement with Waste Management, the operator of the Simi Valley Landfill and Recycling Center, leaving residents' calls for greater transparency about the landfill's environmental and neighborhood impacts without a formal council-level forum.
The Simi Valley Acorn reported that the council split 3-2 on the question, with Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh and Councilmember Elaine Litster supporting the review and councilmembers Rocky Rhodes, Joseph Ayala and Mike Judge opposing it.
The proposed committee would have included up to two council members and city staff. Its scope would have been advisory: reviewing the 2011 agreement, discussing possible changes with Waste Management, and exploring annexing the landfill into Simi Valley. It could have made recommendations but could not have changed the agreement on its own.
How We Got Here
Cavanaugh requested the discussion in September, citing a cascade of community concerns about what the landfill has been accepting. In June 2026, spoiled food from a Boyle Heights warehouse fire was taken to the landfill, prompting odor complaints from residents of the Big Sky neighborhood. County air-quality officials confirmed the odors and issued Waste Management a notice of violation.
The mayor also pointed to lingering confusion over whether debris from the January 2025 Palisades and Eaton fires was hazardous. Some of that debris later tested positive for asbestos, and Simi Valley received the largest share of the roughly 1 million tons transported. Cavanaugh was explicit that she was not accusing Waste Management of wrongdoing, but argued the city has fallen short in keeping residents informed.
"We're not getting the information out to the community well enough," she said, according to the Acorn.
Questions about material from the Santa Susana Field Laboratory — the former rocket engine and nuclear research site in the hills near Simi Valley — have also fueled resident anxiety. Judge defended Waste Management's handling of incoming material, saying the company followed state and county requirements, that the spoiled food was not hazardous and was disposed of appropriately, and that WM had assured the council it would not accept material from the field lab.
The Acorn has previously reported, however, that while contamination from the site's most toxic Area I burn pit goes to a facility in Boise, Idaho, and hazardous waste from the site goes to Kern County or Nevada, material from Santa Susana deemed non-hazardous by officials does go to the Simi Valley Landfill — a distinction that underscores residents' desire for clearer public information.
The 2011 Agreement's History
The landfill agreement has its roots in Waste Management's 2007 request to Ventura County for a landfill expansion. After the city raised environmental and community impact concerns, it formed an ad hoc committee in 2010 to negotiate with the company. The resulting memorandum of understanding valued WM's obligations at more than $1 million in the first year and $90 million to $100 million over the life of the deal. The city estimates it has so far received about $24 million in value.
Former Councilmember Barbara Williamson, who served on that original committee, urged the current council to revisit the agreement, questioning whether some commitments remain unfinished.
Interim Public Works Director Mark Watkins said Waste Management has fulfilled, or continues to contribute toward, many of its obligations — most of which remain in effect until the landfill stops accepting municipal solid waste, expected in roughly 35 years. The agreement also required the city and WM to meet within 15 years to consider revisions; City Manager Samantha Argabrite said the parties met in early 2026 and agreed to leave the terms unchanged.
What the Council Said
Litster said she supports the city's partnership with Waste Management but believes elected officials — not just staff — should help review the agreement and answer residents' questions. She pointed to provisions covering truck traffic, freeway litter cleanup, and the planting of aromatic trees meant to serve as an odor barrier for Big Sky. Argabrite acknowledged those trees remain unplanted because of homeowners association concerns and property issues.
"I don't want to relegate our responsibility to staff," Litster said. "I would like to be there hand-in-hand with them."
Rhodes questioned the need for a committee at all, arguing council members can already ask staff about the agreement and receive recommendations without risking the city's relationship with WM. Ayala suggested an alternative: council members meeting more frequently with Waste Management representatives directly and bringing any proposed changes to the full council.
What Comes Next for Residents
With the committee rejected, the path forward for landfill oversight remains informal. Argabrite said the city can still pursue additional requests, better communication and environmental monitoring with WM, noting the company has met its MOU obligations to date.
After the vote, Cavanaugh said raising the issue still mattered — even without a formal committee. "I have to support my community," she said. "They got heard and I think that's what's important. Whether it's an ad hoc committee or not, we need to have more conversations and more information out to the community members."
For Simi Valley residents — particularly those in Big Sky who lived through the June odor episodes and watched wildfire debris trucks roll along the 118 — the practical question is whether that promise of improved communication materializes without a structured council role. The landfill is expected to continue accepting municipal solid waste for decades, meaning the relationship between the city, its operator and its neighbors will remain a live local issue for years to come.
Reported by 805.life
Researched and written drawing on primary sources. Additional reporting: Simi Valley Acorn.
City
Simi ValleyAdditional Reporting
Simi Valley AcornPublished
November 20, 2026
Reported and written by 805.life
Explore Simi ValleyAll Simi Valley NewsMore News from Simi Valley
Simi ValleyLawsuit fights Newsom’s death row commutations
Hey neighbors, you may have seen the headline in the Simi Valley Acorn: a lawsuit filed this week aims to block Gov. Newsom's plan to commute the death sentences of 548 inmates statewide — 15 of them sentenced right here in Ventura County. The suit comes from the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, joined by prosecutors, law enforcement groups, and victims' rights advocates who argue the governor is sidestepping constitutional safeguards. This isn't just a Sacramento story. For families and communities touched by these cases, it's deeply personal, and it's worth paying attention to how the legal fight unfolds. Whatever your view on the death penalty, the question of how much power a governor has to reshape sentences matters to all of us. We'll keep following this one locally. In the meantime, it's a good reminder that decisions made far from Simi Valley can still land close to home.
Simi ValleySimi prepares for winter storms, schedules community meetings
Simi Valley is getting ahead of the rain this year, and honestly, that's the kind of quiet prep work that makes a difference when the storms actually hit. City crews have already cleared storm basins and drainage facilities, hauling away more than 22 tons of debris, and they're continuing inspections of culverts, storm drains and channels across town. If you've lived here a while, you know how fast those November and December downpours can turn a clogged drain into a flooded street. The city is also scheduling a series of community meetings to help residents get ready for potentially heavy rainfall. That's your chance to ask questions, learn where trouble spots tend to be, and figure out what to have on hand before the first big system rolls through. The Simi Valley Acorn has the details on the schedule. Take a few minutes to check your own gutters and sandbags, and keep an eye out for those meeting dates. A little prep now beats a soggy scramble later.
Simi ValleyAyala leads Abele in tooclose to-call council race
Simi Valley neighbors, if you thought the District 1 council race was settled, think again. Two weeks after Election Day, Joseph Ayala has edged ahead of Jill Abele as Ventura County keeps working through the remaining ballots. This one is about as tight as it gets, and every vote truly matters. For those of us in District 1, this seat shapes decisions on housing, traffic, and the everyday quality-of-life issues we care about most. The Simi Valley Acorn has been tracking the ups and downs closely, and the latest numbers show just how fluid things can be until every ballot is counted. So stay tuned, Simi Valley. Whether you're Team Ayala or Team Abele, this is democracy in action—and a good reminder that local elections can come down to a handful of votes. We'll be watching for the final tally.